Archived Story

UM response of Griz arrests under spotlight
By TRISTAN SCOTT of the Missoulian

Jim O'Day says University of Montana coaches warn student-athletes about running afoul of the law. They preach responsibility. They promote student mentoring programs and encourage civic engagement.

“It is stressed daily to these men and women that they are in the public eye, that they represent the University of Montana, and if they make a poor decision, they're going to be digging themselves out of a big hole,” said O'Day, UM's athletics director.

But in the past 16 months, 10 football players have had run-ins with the law. Some infractions were relatively minor, such as offensive lineman J.D. Quinn's pair of DUI arrests, which he resolved in court by pleading guilty to a single count of DUI per se. Other affirmed misdeeds, such last November's violent home invasion, which saw a man pistol-whipped and shocked with a stun gun at the hands of four Grizzly football players, were more alarming instances of athletic turpitude.

Former cornerback Jimmy Wilson has been in custody at a Los Angeles County jailhouse on $2 million bail since June 2007, when he was charged with the shooting death of his aunt's boyfriend. Wilson has maintained his innocence.

The latest black eye to UM athletics came on Sept. 19, when county prosecutors say a dormitory surveillance camera recorded three redshirt freshmen assaulting a UM student, knocking the 18-year-old man unconscious and breaking his jaw.

Those incidents, taken along with a series of crimes involving one-time Montana State University athletes - including a murder and a sprawling drug ring - have gone a long way toward besmirching Montana's athletics programs.

Montana State sought a review by the NCAA and followed up on its recommendations. At the University of Montana, officials have plenty of cause to examine how they should address a chronic discipline problem.

O'Day says every student-athlete is made keenly aware of an individual sport's conduct code, which is more strict than the campuswide student conduct code.

“As a student coming onto campus, they know what is expected of them, and they understand that there are consequences if they don't abide by the rules,” O'Day said.

On an academic level, UM's student-athletes regularly best the general student body's overall GPA, and have access to a variety of academic guidance that is specific to athletes.

Darr Tucknott coordinates UM's athletic academic services along with another full-time employee, helping athletes stay eligible and meet graduation requirements. They serve as academic advisers separate from the advisers assigned to every student.

Charles Palmer, a performance psychologist for the Department of Health and Human Performance, teaches classes about decision making and career choices, and the athletics department channeled additional funding for Palmer so he could be available to athletes more often.

In the past year, UM has also hired Murray Pierce, a black former Grizzly football player, as a part-time mentor for all minority students.

“We constantly monitor the academic successes of our athletes,” O'Day said. “Our academic advisers are in constant contact with the athletes, and if they see any red flags, they are right on top of them.”

And while it is impossible to monitor every student-athlete every moment of the day, and no amount of guidance can fully safeguard against misbehavior, last month's alleged assault has begged the question - can the university do more?

UM Vice President Jim Foley says the athletics department will continue to assess ways to improve student mentoring and academic support, in addition to the overall culture of athletics. However, no immediate changes were identified in response to the recent alleged assault.

In 2006, MSU requested that the NCAA review its athletic programs following unacceptable academic progress rates in the football program and a rash of crimes involving current and former student-athletes. The university then assembled a committee called One Team to make recommendations for MSU's response to the review, and released a report in April 2008.

“This report is not a pat on the back for the university. It is a realistic examination of progress made and offers recommendations for further improvement,” said Mike Redburn, an MSU education professor who chaired the One Team committee.

Cami Bechtold, MSU's associate athletic director, said the One Team Committee organized its work around four key themes: recruitment; academic support and mentoring; program culture; orientation and integration of student-athletes into the campus and community.

“We focus a lot on helping our students develop their character and their moral compass, and with the added staff in the academic center we are finally able to do that, not just in an academic sense but in helping develop the whole person,” Bechtold said.

In the six months since the report was released, MSU has expanded an academic center for student-athletes, increasing both its size and resources. The center, which is housed in the field-house complex, employs two full-time academic coordinators and a life skills coordinator. That new position was filled by Jon Taylor, a Bobcat alum who was injured in the NFL before returning to Bozeman with an eye toward academic administration.

“Jon's office door opens up into the academic center, so if you're a student sitting at a computer you can look over and see him,” said Tracy Ellig, a spokesman for MSU. “It's that kind of interaction that really helps connect our incoming students to the campus community.”

MSU has also adopted a program called “Winning with Character,” which was originally developed for the University of Georgia football team, but has since spread to schools around the nation.

“It's designed to provide character ethics and leadership training for student-athletes,” Bechtold said. “It challenges athletes to reach their full potential on the field, in the classroom, and in the community.”

Ellig said the university had identified a number of changes in the athletics department prior to the One Team report, and will continue to actively evaluate the success of student-athletes, both academically and socially.

“We feel we are headed in the right direction, but that we've still got a lot more work to do. ... This is a process of changing a culture, and changing a culture cannot be done overnight. It is a long-term process,” he said. “This is only the beginning.”


Add your comment now! Write your comment in the form below.
(Email address is for verification only. If you'd like to email a story, look for the link above)
Current Word Count:
   

Kate W wrote on Oct 12, 2008 1:41 AM:

" it is ridiculous for the Missoulian to refer to J.D. Quinns "pair of DUI arrests" as a minor infraction. A DUI is a serious offense and a pair is even worse! Lets not down play the seriousness of his actions. "

Bill Welch wrote on Oct 12, 2008 6:00 AM:

" Athens, Georgia — After Michael Lemon's dismissal from Georgia's football team, the Bulldogs can only hope that their trouble-filled offseason has finally bottomed out.

Lemon, a sophomore defensive end from Lizella, was kicked off the team by coach Mark Richt 11 days after being charged with the felony crime of aggravated battery.

Lemon was the seventh Georgia football player to be arrested in the first seven months of this year. "

Meggen wrote on Oct 12, 2008 7:03 AM:

" If the athletes haven't learned right from wrong before entering kindergarten, they will never learn it. The college athletes in the story know the difference and have chosen 'wrong'. UM officials choose to ignore this and fund special classes, psychologists, etc knowing it won't make a difference, but hey it looks like UM is trying to address the issue. All fluff and no substance. And our money. Get rid of the baby-sitting programs for student athletes. "

CGlass wrote on Oct 12, 2008 8:01 AM:

" Why not a simple zero-tolerance policy - academically and legally? No exceptions. A policy made very clear in the recruiting process. Put the onus on the student/player to be 100% responsible for their actions. If they want to play for UM – here’s the deal. Many have been privileged to play ball thanks to scholarships. Make them earn their keep. Stop the babysitting and spending more money. "

John Conlan wrote on Oct 12, 2008 10:19 AM:

" Great reporting except the wording concerning the Quinn DUI arrests. Being the victim of a DUI accident a few years ago in Spokane was hardly viewed by my wife and I as a "relatively minor" offense. Our car was totaled and my wife had thousands of dollars in medical bills because some irresposible person took out the car while drunk and decided to ram into us at 60 mph. "

g wrote on Oct 12, 2008 11:13 AM:

" If you had a ZERO TOLERANCE policy, these things would ramp down. But with the hand holding and wrist slap policy currently in place, nothing will change. Throw a few of these upstanding citizens off your football team for good and see how it affects the behavior of the rest. Do it immediately, not waiting months for some sort of investigation. Hide and watch how fast things will change with the rest of these model citizens you have recruited. You will be amazed what will happen if your policy is "They are gone immediately if something wrong happens". "

JimS wrote on Oct 12, 2008 11:40 AM:

" I'm sure Coach Hauck wants to strangle these idiots who can't function without a full time babysitter. They all deserve to be expelled and given jail time. Questioning whether any of them truly qualify or deserve to be griz in the first place are very appropriate. Out of 14,000 students, a few high profile idiots sure make everyone feel sick. The pressure on little league coaches these days is intense. I can only imagine the pressure running a major sports program. Even Joe Paterno has had trouble with knucklheads. Coach Hauck runs a great program and if I cringe everytime I see a griz in the police blotter, he must really feel let down. Kids are given a chance to prove themselves when no one is watching them. Some just simply fail miserably. "

Donna wrote on Oct 12, 2008 1:37 PM:

" Maybe when recruiting look at the whole picture. I have a relative playing in ND right now. They extremly happy with his performance. He competed against one of UM's red shirt team member. Difference is my relative is highly respected but didn't have a popular family to speak on his behalf. "

Doug wrote on Oct 12, 2008 9:20 PM:

" Coddling student athletes who are well aware of the rules and of their expectations isn't the answer. Set a firm example. Get them gone! There are plenty of other student athletes willing to take their place. As a student in the mid to late 70s, I can well remember the days when there was much talk of eliminating the football program - partly because it didn't pay for itself and partly because of the constant problems involving members of the football program. "

ck slaughter wrote on Oct 13, 2008 8:41 AM:

" Perhaps a banner protest of a game would send a clearer message to the recruiters and the officials that keep trivializing criminal behavior of these students.We have kids in the military so they can get an education they otherwise can't afford.Why are we supporting thugs? "

New Dad wrote on Oct 13, 2008 9:42 AM:

" This is a leadership issue. Fire Dennisson, fire O'Day, and fire Hauck before more innocent citizens are hurt or killed. All three men have significantly damaged this community in their quest to achieve Division II football dominance. Priorities, anyone? Dennisson in particular should be ashamed of what has become of the beautiful UM campus and culture he inherited, then wasted. "

Jesse wrote on Oct 13, 2008 3:41 PM:

" BOO Bobby Hauck and his crappy recruitment. Don't tell me the guys who broke into the house and tazed one of the residents didn't have prior records. Recruit thugs and hooligans, and that's what your program will be known for. Kudo's to Bozeman for actually affecting change and not just giving it lip service "

Matt wrote on Oct 13, 2008 10:03 PM:

" I believe that Universities around the country, not just UM or MSU, place a higher value on athletics rather than academics. College is meant to be a place of higher education. Sports should be relegated to last on UM's and MSU's list of important matters. It's time to consider the academic future of students who are paying for additions to stadiums or new jerseys. "

WAKE UP FOLKS wrote on Oct 14, 2008 12:12 PM:

" How in the world are they suppose to know what they've done when nothing would ever show up on a background check from their high school days.

2nd, Griz athletes, as noted in this article, have the best GPAs & better than a majority of the non-athletes on campus. If any of you know Coach Hauck, you'd realize the importance he places on academics knowing full well the reality that they will have to face a "real" life after graduation!

3rd, not to excuse the behavior, I would imagine that many of us have witnessed or be told about similar incidents at some point in our lives -- especailly when in high school or college. It seems that someone in the legal system is out for blood at the expense of some kids. You can't tell me that we know ALL of the story! Nor, can you tell me that you don't know a single incident of this nature from your days growing up?

The last I looked, the football team is 5-1 & it seems to me that the fair weathered fans of the University of Montana aren't happy! Perhaps the pressure the fans place on these KIDS to be PERFECT & the BOOS they get when they aren't contribute to their stress! They're students & kids! Perhaps our full support would help -- winning OR losing! "

Bill wrote on Oct 14, 2008 5:34 PM:

" These kids are given a gift by representing the University. They get told time and time again to stay out of trouble. If they screw it up, get rid of them. There are plenty more kids who could step up in their place. I would rather see good kids, kids that are good role models, giving it there all, and maybe losing a couple more games, rather than seeing thugs and problem athletes in the paper every week. The University needs to remember that all their athletes are looked up to by the kids in our community. Zero tolerence should be enforced. The choice between right and wrong is easy, if one cannot make the right choices, than it should be "bye bye". But maybe the University does not care about how it's athletes are perceived as long as the stadium gets filled every weekend. "

Kori Dee wrote on Oct 16, 2008 11:31 AM:

" I am very pleased to see the UM Administration addressing this issue. I am troubled that the reporter would consider multiple DUI's "a relatively minor infraction." All of these incidents are severe in their own right and should be addressed accordingly by the UM Administration as they are doing. "

jerry wrote on Oct 18, 2008 5:17 PM:

" People die everyday at the hands of others operating vehicles while intoxicated. A DUI should never be written off as a minor offense. We can only hope, J.D. Quinn has realized he was fortunate not to have hurt anyone (either time) and will be more responsible from here on out. If he doesn't it will be his fault and no one elses. As a young man the responsibility lies with him. Those of you who are stereotyping the entire team as a bunch of thugs are just plain wrong. Do you think Cole Berquist is a thug? What about Mariani or Dow or 4.0 student Selle? These guys as well as most of the other players are doing a great job and deserved to be supported as does Coach Hauck who recruited them too. "


|

Subscribe to the Missoulian today — get 2 weeks free!